top of page
Writer's pictureBrinkley Law

Defending Against Unlawful Police Stops in Indiana Drug Cases

Being stopped by the police can be a stressful experience, particularly if it leads to drug charges. In Indiana, as in other states, the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution protects individuals from unreasonable searches and seizures. This protection is crucial in drug cases, where unlawful police stops can lead to evidence being excluded from trial. Understanding your rights and the legal defenses available can be pivotal in defending against drug charges resulting from an unlawful stop.


What Constitutes an Unlawful Police Stop?


A police stop is considered unlawful if it violates the Fourth Amendment. For a stop to be lawful, police officers must have reasonable suspicion that the person they are stopping is involved in criminal activity. This suspicion must be based on specific and articulable facts, rather than mere hunches or assumptions.


Common Defenses Against Unlawful Stops in Drug Cases

  1. Lack of Reasonable Suspicion: One of the primary defenses against an unlawful stop is arguing that the police did not have reasonable suspicion to initiate the stop. If the officers cannot provide a valid reason for the stop, any evidence obtained as a result may be deemed inadmissible in court. Example: Suppose an officer stops a vehicle simply because the driver looks nervous. If there are no other factors or behaviors that suggest criminal activity, the stop might be considered unlawful due to the lack of reasonable suspicion.

  2. Pretextual Stops: Sometimes, officers use minor traffic violations as a pretext to stop a vehicle they suspect is involved in more serious criminal activity. While pretextual stops can be legal if the initial reason for the stop is valid, any subsequent search must still adhere to constitutional standards. Example: If an officer stops a car for a broken taillight but quickly escalates to searching the vehicle without any additional reasonable suspicion or probable cause, the search might be challenged as unlawful.

  3. Illegal Search and Seizure: Even if a stop is lawful, the search that follows must also be conducted legally. Officers generally need probable cause to search a vehicle without a warrant. If a search is conducted without consent, probable cause, or a valid warrant, the evidence obtained may be suppressed. Example: If an officer searches a car's trunk without the driver’s consent and without any visible evidence suggesting illegal activity, any drugs found may be excluded from evidence due to the illegal search.

  4. Violation of Miranda Rights: If a stop leads to an arrest, officers must inform the individual of their Miranda rights before conducting any interrogation. Failure to do so can result in any statements made by the defendant being excluded from evidence. Example: If an officer arrests someone during a traffic stop and begins questioning them about drug possession without reading the Miranda rights, any incriminating statements may be inadmissible in court.


Legal Procedures for Challenging Unlawful Stops


To challenge an unlawful stop and suppress evidence, a defense attorney can file a motion to suppress. This legal motion argues that the evidence obtained during the stop should not be admitted in court because it was acquired through unconstitutional means. During the suppression hearing, the defense will present arguments and evidence to demonstrate that the stop or subsequent search violated the defendant’s Fourth Amendment rights.


The Role of a Defense Attorney


Having an experienced defense attorney is crucial in drug cases involving unlawful stops. A skilled attorney will:

  • Investigate the Stop: Thoroughly examine the circumstances of the stop to identify any violations of constitutional rights.

  • File Motions: Prepare and file motions to suppress evidence obtained through unlawful stops or searches.

  • Represent in Court: Advocate on behalf of the defendant during suppression hearings and throughout the trial process.

  • Negotiate: Work to negotiate plea deals or reduced charges if appropriate, based on the weaknesses in the prosecution’s case.


Conclusion

Defending against drug charges stemming from unlawful police stops in Indiana requires a robust understanding of constitutional protections and legal strategies. By challenging the legality of the stop and any subsequent search, an accused can potentially have critical evidence excluded, which may lead to reduced charges or even dismissal of the case. If you or a loved one is facing drug charges after an unlawful stop, it is essential to seek the guidance of an experienced defense attorney who can help protect your rights and build a strong defense.


For more information or to discuss your case, please contact Brinkley Law today at 317-643-1813. We are dedicated to providing the highest level of legal representation and ensuring that your rights are upheld in the face of criminal charges.


0 comments

Comments


bottom of page