top of page

Is a Consultation With a Lawyer Confidential in Indiana?

Oct 15
5 min read

Generally, yes. In Indiana, what you tell a lawyer during a consultation is protected even if you never hire that lawyer. The Indiana Rules of Professional Conduct say a lawyer may not use or reveal information learned in a consultation with a prospective client, except in limited circumstances (Rule 1.18). The attorney-client privilege can also protect communications made while you are seeking legal help, whether or not you have paid a fee. There are limits, such as when other people are present or when the conversation is about committing a future crime or fraud.

Key points

  • A person who discusses with a lawyer the possibility of hiring them is a "prospective client" under Indiana Rule of Professional Conduct 1.18.

  • A lawyer generally may not use or reveal what a prospective client shares, even if the person never hires the lawyer.

  • The attorney-client privilege can cover a preliminary meeting, and it does not depend on paying a fee.

  • Having third parties present, using recorded phone lines, or seeking help with a future crime or fraud can cost you the attorney-client privilege.

Who counts as a prospective client?

Under Indiana Rule of Professional Conduct 1.18, a prospective client is a person who discusses with a lawyer the possibility of forming a lawyer-client relationship. The protection applies even if the conversation is brief.

The commentary to the rule notes an important limit. A person who sends information to a lawyer on their own, without any reasonable expectation that the lawyer is willing to discuss representing them, is not a prospective client. For that reason, it is usually best to share only basic contact information and a short description of your issue until you are speaking with the lawyer.

What a lawyer must keep confidential after a consultation

Even when no attorney-client relationship forms, a lawyer who has learned information from a prospective client may not use or reveal that information, except as the rules allow for former clients (Rule 1.18(b)).

The rule also limits conflicts of interest. A lawyer who received information from you that could be significantly harmful to you generally may not represent someone else against you in the same or a substantially related matter. That restriction can extend to the lawyer's firm. Exceptions apply if both you and the other client give informed consent, confirmed in writing, or if the lawyer took reasonable steps to limit what they learned, is screened from the matter, receives no part of the fee, and you are promptly notified in writing (Rule 1.18(c) and (d)).

Confidentiality and attorney-client privilege are related but different

The duty of confidentiality is an ethical rule. It limits what a lawyer may reveal or use, in or out of court (Rules 1.6 and 1.18).

The attorney-client privilege is a rule of evidence. Indiana law provides that attorneys shall not be required to testify about confidential communications made to them in the course of their professional business, or about the advice they gave (IC 34-46-3-1).

Indiana courts have applied the privilege to communications made while a person is trying to obtain legal advice. The Indiana Supreme Court has said the privilege depends on the confidential relationship between client and attorney, not on whether litigation is pending or a fee was paid (Colman v. Heidenreich, 1978). The Indiana Court of Appeals has said the preliminary nature of a meeting does not remove it from the privilege (Corll v. Edward D. Jones & Co., 1995).

When a consultation may not be protected

The protections are strong, but they have limits.

  • Third parties in the room. Statements made in front of a third person who is not part of the legal relationship may not be privileged. Ask the lawyer before bringing a friend or family member into the conversation.

  • Recorded phone lines. Jail and prison calls are usually recorded. The Indiana Supreme Court has held that a person who continued talking about a case on a jail phone after being warned the call may be recorded waived the privilege (Bassett v. State, 2008).

  • Future crimes or fraud. Communications made to get help committing a crime or fraud are not privileged (Green v. State, Indiana Supreme Court, 1971).

  • Narrow ethical exceptions. Indiana's confidentiality rules allow limited disclosures in certain situations, such as preventing reasonably certain death or substantial bodily harm (Rule 1.6).

Does it matter if the consultation is by phone or video?

The same rules apply whether you meet in person, by phone, or by video. To protect your privacy, take the call from a private place, use your own device and account, and avoid shared email accounts or workplace computers.

Does paying for a consultation change confidentiality?

No. Under Indiana law, the protections do not depend on whether you paid for the consultation. What matters is that you were seeking legal advice in confidence from a lawyer.

How to get the most from your consultation

  • Be honest and complete. The lawyer can only give useful advice if they know the facts, including the unfavorable ones.

  • Bring documents. Court papers, letters, contracts, police reports, and a timeline of events all help. Our consultation checklist lists what to bring.

  • Write down your questions in advance so you cover what matters most to you.

  • Ask about next steps, including deadlines and what happens if you decide to hire the firm.

Frequently asked questions

Can a lawyer tell the police what I said in a consultation?

Generally, no. A lawyer's duty of confidentiality and the attorney-client privilege protect what you share while seeking legal advice, subject to limited exceptions such as communications made to further a future crime or fraud.

If I do not hire the lawyer, is what I said still confidential?

Yes. Under Rule 1.18, a lawyer may not use or reveal information learned in a consultation with a prospective client, except as the rules allow, even if you never hire the lawyer.

Can the lawyer I consulted represent the other side?

Generally not in the same or a substantially related matter if the lawyer received information that could be significantly harmful to you, unless you and the other client both give informed consent, confirmed in writing. In limited cases, other lawyers at the same firm may take the matter if the lawyer you consulted is screened from it and you are promptly notified in writing.

Is a free consultation confidential?

Generally, yes. The same protections, and the same limits, apply whether or not you paid a fee.

Ready to talk with a lawyer?

Brinkley Law handles criminal defense, expungement, business law, and personal injury matters in Indiana. You can schedule a consultation online at a time that works for you. To learn more first, visit our pages on criminal defense, expungement, business law, and personal injury.

Brinkley Law, 8888 Keystone Crossing, Suite 1300, Indianapolis, Indiana 46240.

This article provides general information about Indiana law and is not legal advice. Reading it or contacting Brinkley Law does not create an attorney-client relationship. The application of the law depends on the facts of each matter.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page